top of page
  • Writer's pictureCapt.Casey

The Secrets of Sheepshead Fishing in Sarasota & Siesta Key

Hey there, fellow anglers! I'm Capt. Casey, your trusted guide to the thrilling world of fishing in the pristine waters of Sarasota and Siesta Key. Today, let's unravel the mysteries of sheepshead fishing, a pursuit that requires skill, patience, and a bit of finesse.

How to Catch Sheepshead in Sarasota & Siesta Key

The Sheepshead's Habitat:

February signals the spawning season for these captivating creatures, drawing them to the close reefs, shallow water canals, and various other spots in our beautiful waters. With their distinct spikey dorsal fins, human-like teeth, and striking black and white stripes, sheepshead make for a challenging yet rewarding catch and great photo opportunity.

Best Fishing Locations:

"Find Docks or Rocks and you'll find the sheepshead." The prime spots to target sheepshead include:

  • Close reefs

  • Rocks and docks in the passes like Venice Inlet, Big Pass, New Pass, and Longboat Pass

  • Any docks in the bay and intracoastal areas (drive by and look, you should spot them)

Best Bait and Tackle:

To entice these picky fish, opt for small live shrimp on a #1 hook with a #5 split shot. Adjust your leader based on water clarity, using 15lb fluorocarbon for clear water and 25lb fluorocarbon for murkier conditions. Prime locations include fishing around rocks and docks, where sheepshead are known to congregate. When fishing the close reefs use a #1 hook, heavier 1/2oz - 3/4oz egg sinker and 25lb-30lb fluorocarbon leader.

Choosing the right bait:

This is crucial for a successful fishing expedition. These discerning fish are particularly fond of crustaceans and mollusks, so baits that mimic their natural prey are highly effective. Consider using live or fresh shrimp, fiddler crabs, and small crabs as they closely resemble the sheepshead's preferred diet. Sand fleas, barnacles, and even small pieces of clams can also prove enticing to these omnivorous feeders. Rig your bait to imitate the movement of their prey, and don't forget to adjust your tactics based on seasonal changes in sheepshead behavior. By presenting baits that align with their culinary preferences, you'll increase your chances of enticing sheepshead to bite and enjoy a rewarding day on the water

Spotting and Hooking Them:

Keep a keen eye out for sheepshead swimming just below the surface near docks or nosing up to pilings, feasting on barnacle. Other effective baits include small crabs and sandflies. However, the real challenge lies in catching and reeling them in.

Catching and Reeling Them In:

  1. Choose the Right Conditions: Sheepshead are more active in moving currents, and they may not feed as much during slack tides when the water is stagnant. Keep this in mind when planning your fishing expedition.

  2. Exercise Patience: These are tricky fish to catch. Unlike some others, they tend to chew on the hook or bait without it feeling like a solid connection. Patience is key in this game.

  3. Maintain a Tight Line: Keep your line tight at all times. Even when reeling extremely slowly, ensure there's no slack to feel every tap from the crafty sheepshead.

  4. Reeling Technique: After the initial tap, start reeling very slowly until you sense a stronger pull. Resist the urge to set the hook immediately. Instead, continue reeling a bit faster.

  5. Handling Biting: If you feel consistent biting, gently pull back on the rod, allowing the hook to set in their soft lip. Keeping the pressure on the fish is crucial for a successful catch. Pulling back too aggressive leads to the hook pulling out and losing the fish.

  6. Use a Net: Always use a net when landing these fish. Lifting them out of the water can easily dislodge the hook, and we want to make sure your hard work pays off.

Filleting Challenges:

Filleting sheepshead can be a bit challenging due to their substantial bones that can resist your knife and a skin that quickly dulls your blade. Despite this, the effort is undoubtedly worth the delectable reward.

Culinary Delight:

Despite the filleting challenge, sheepshead are renowned for their delicious taste, resembling the flavor of lobster with a different texture (if it's cooked correctly and dipped in butter.) If you're a seafood enthusiast that like fresh white meat with zero fishy flavor, then sheepshead should be on your menu.

There you have it – a comprehensive guide to mastering the art of sheepshead fishing in Sarasota and Siesta Key. Join me on one of our Sarasota Fishing Charters to experience the thrill firsthand. Happy fishing, folks! 🎣


bottom of page